At Singleton Reynolds, our people are what makes us great. We come together every day with the common goal of providing exceptional legal services and ensuring we go above and beyond for each and every client.
The range of backgrounds of the partners, counsel, associates and staff of Singleton Reynolds enables us to offer a broad range of services.
Singleton Reynolds’ lawyers spend a significant amount of time researching and thinking about how industry or legislative changes could affect your business.
Singleton Urquhart Reynolds Vogel LLP is recognized as a leader in construction and infrastructure, insurance, commercial litigation, real estate and business law.
Singleton Reynolds has offices to serve you in Vancouver and Toronto.
How was Singleton Reynolds first established? Find out more here.
Recognizing the leadership that contributes to the company successes.
Singleton Reynolds prides itself in being a leader in corporate social responsibility. We encourage diversity, charity, mentorship, civic dedication and neighbourhood support.
Singleton Reynolds strives to understand the balance between your career and your personal goals and encourages our legal and operations staff in the pursuit of their interests outside of the firm.
We are always on the lookout for talented professionals to contribute to our team. Singleton Reynolds offers a professional and challenging work environment, with a competitive compensation and benefits package.
Our goal is to develop strong lawyers from student right through to partner. Mentoring and training start when you are a student and continue throughout your practice.
In litigation, evidence is essential; in the online era, much of that evidence is internet-based. But online evidence can be difficult to bring before the court in British Columbia.
Many internet companies are headquartered and house their data on servers in the United States and other countries, introducing complex questions of jurisdiction when that data becomes evidence. The rewards of grappling with these questions can be enormous, as browsing histories, emails, IP addresses, metadata or deleted content can be crucial to your case.
Online data can help prove crucial facts, such as an individual’s identity, their knowledge at a point in time, or even the presence of actionable damages in all types of lawsuits, including defamation, fraud, and commercial disputes. Unsurprisingly, then, such evidence is increasingly a critical piece of modern litigation strategy. But admitting it at trial often involves a number of procedural hurdles.
Despite the 21st century’s increasing interconnectivity, obtaining evidence in B.C. from foreign jurisdictions remains resolutely old-fashioned. In Equustek Solutions Inc. v. Jack, Madam Justice Fenlon aptly noted that the internet frustrated traditional territorial jurisdiction of the courts, and that the courts must adapt to the changing nature of human commerce and information interchange in the “borderless electronic web of the internet”. Unfortunately, the B.C. Rules of Court have not caught up.
When a witness (individual or corporate) is located in a foreign jurisdiction, will not attend trial willingly, and cannot be compelled to attend because of the court’s limited jurisdiction, but their evidence is necessary to a claim or defence, litigants can apply to the court for what are known as “letters of request” or “letters rogatory”. The court can issue a letter of request to the foreign court, seeking judicial assistance and requesting that the foreign court compel the witness to attend the deposition.
The letter of request is then given effect by counsel in the foreign jurisdiction where the witness resides. The procedure for giving effect to the B.C. order varies by jurisdiction. In California, for example (where Google and Facebook are headquartered), the Code of Civil Procedure allows a lawyer to issue a “foreign subpoena” without resorting to the court. In other jurisdictions, such as Washington (where Microsoft does business) and Arizona (the home of GoDaddy), an application to the state court may be necessary.
The process is unwieldy, and involves sending letters of request to the Undersecretary of State for External Affairs of Canada in Ottawa, to be forwarded through diplomatic channels, and then to the foreign court for assistance, aided by counsel. The evidence then meanders back to the parties through the same channels, and the process could take years. The first of many problems with this clunky procedure is this: The Undersecretary of State for External Affairs is no longer a position in Canada’s federal government. (Cabinet positions may change, but some rules stay the same.)
Luckily, more expeditious channels exist. However, coordinating a process consistent with B.C. law, international law and the law in the foreign jurisdiction requires strategy and finesse. It also depends on the kind of evidence to be admitted and the jurisdiction where it is to be found.
B.C.’s process for obtaining foreign evidence is also out of step with many other jurisdictions, which have turned to Mutual Legal Assistance Treaties (MLATs) instead. These treaties seek to replace the common law’s reliance on letters of request with a more efficient and reliable process. However, for complex constitutional reasons, Canada’s federal structure precludes it from being a signatory to MLATs.
While the specific steps involved in obtaining letters of request may change in the coming years (one wonders, for instance, how long a non-existent civil servant can play a starring role), the overall process for obtaining foreign evidence is likely to remain complex in Canada due to our federal structure.
Combine that stubborn fact with our society’s ongoing online migration, and it is more important than ever that litigants have an effective strategy for identifying and obtaining foreign evidence where necessary.
When your litigation may turn on evidence of online activities, turn to counsel with the expertise to get that evidence before the courts.
For more information on civil litigation and obtaining foreign evidence, please contact Claire.
For more information, please contact:
News + Insights | Mar 11, 2019
Firm News | Jan 2, 2019
Firm News | Dec 17, 2018
Or call toll-free at 1-877-682-4404 or (604) 682-7474 (Vancouver) or (416) 585-8600 (Toronto)
This field is required